Crayon Marks

"RF" <fwdixon.RemoveThis@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:bbf871f5-dbbd-4274-842f-4103ca6803fc@e53g2000hsa.googlegroups.com...
On Jul 19, 4:27 pm, "Francis A. Miniter" <famini....RemoveThis@comcast.net>
wrote:
>> I have a book that has crayon marks on the dust jacket. Any
>> suggestions for removing them?
>>
>> Francis A. Miniter

>Goo Gone

Expert advice there Francis.

Over half of his stock has had crayon marks on it at sometime.

Victor
 >> Stay informed about: Crayon Marks 

On Jul 28, 10:41 pm, "Francis A. Miniter" <famini... RemoveThis @comcast.net>
wrote:
> RF wrote:
> > On Jul 19, 4:27 pm, "Francis A. Miniter" <famini... RemoveThis @comcast.net>
> > wrote:
> >> I have a book that has crayon marks on the dust jacket.  Any
> >> suggestions for removing them?
>
> >> Francis A. Miniter
>
> > Goo Gone
>
> The dust jacket in question was paper, which presented some
> problems.  On one part of the marking, I used a pink eraser.
>   It was somewhat effective, but could not get all the
> crayon out.  On a second part, I used just Goo Gone, which
> at first dissolved and spread the crayon marking.  (I should
> note that I first determined that I tested Goo Gone on a
> piece of plain paper to determine that it left no stain
> marks.  It does not.)  Repeated applications removed most
> but not all the stain, and by itself, not as much as the
> pink eraser.  On a small, third portion, I first used the
> pink eraser and then the Goo Gone, and that seemed to yield
> the best results, though still not perfect.
>
> The problem with the eraser is wearing away of the paper
> density.  The problem with the Goo Gone is the dispersion of
> the stain into the fabric.  A judicious use of the one to
> limit crayon thickness, then the other to prevent excessive
> paper wear, seems to be best.
>
> A final try with Xylene did not improve the situation.
>
> I note that Goo Gone works fine with dust jackets having a
> coating over the paper.
>
> The dust jacket is generally better than before I started.
>
> Francis A. Miniter

Try applying the Goo Gone to a paper towel/tissue or cotton ball and
gently rub the mark.
 >> Stay informed about: Crayon Marks 

RF wrote:
> On Jul 19, 4:27 pm, "Francis A. Miniter" <famini....DeleteThis@comcast.net>
> wrote:
>> I have a book that has crayon marks on the dust jacket. Any
>> suggestions for removing them?
>>
>> Francis A. Miniter
>
> Goo Gone


The dust jacket in question was paper, which presented some
problems. On one part of the marking, I used a pink eraser.
It was somewhat effective, but could not get all the
crayon out. On a second part, I used just Goo Gone, which
at first dissolved and spread the crayon marking. (I should
note that I first determined that I tested Goo Gone on a
piece of plain paper to determine that it left no stain
marks. It does not.) Repeated applications removed most
but not all the stain, and by itself, not as much as the
pink eraser. On a small, third portion, I first used the
pink eraser and then the Goo Gone, and that seemed to yield
the best results, though still not perfect.

The problem with the eraser is wearing away of the paper
density. The problem with the Goo Gone is the dispersion of
the stain into the fabric. A judicious use of the one to
limit crayon thickness, then the other to prevent excessive
paper wear, seems to be best.

A final try with Xylene did not improve the situation.

I note that Goo Gone works fine with dust jackets having a
coating over the paper.

The dust jacket is generally better than before I started.


Francis A. Miniter
 >> Stay informed about: Crayon Marks 

On Jul 28, 9:41 pm, "Francis A. Miniter" <famini... RemoveThis @comcast.net>
wrote:
> RF wrote:
> > On Jul 19, 4:27 pm, "Francis A. Miniter" <famini... RemoveThis @comcast.net>
> > wrote:
> >> I have a book that has crayon marks on the dust jacket.  Any
> >> suggestions for removing them?
>
> >> Francis A. Miniter
>
> > Goo Gone
>
> The dust jacket in question was paper, which presented some
> problems.  On one part of the marking, I used a pink eraser.
>   It was somewhat effective, but could not get all the
> crayon out.  On a second part, I used just Goo Gone, which
> at first dissolved and spread the crayon marking.  (I should
> note that I first determined that I tested Goo Gone on a
> piece of plain paper to determine that it left no stain
> marks.  It does not.)  Repeated applications removed most
> but not all the stain, and by itself, not as much as the
> pink eraser.  On a small, third portion, I first used the
> pink eraser and then the Goo Gone, and that seemed to yield
> the best results, though still not perfect.
>
> The problem with the eraser is wearing away of the paper
> density.  The problem with the Goo Gone is the dispersion of
> the stain into the fabric.  A judicious use of the one to
> limit crayon thickness, then the other to prevent excessive
> paper wear, seems to be best.
>
> A final try with Xylene did not improve the situation.
>
> I note that Goo Gone works fine with dust jackets having a
> coating over the paper.
>
> The dust jacket is generally better than before I started.
>
> Francis A. Miniter

I've had the best success with Thoro (dry-cleaning fluid).

If the crayon marks are heavy, I use a single-edge razor
blade, held flat against the surface, to lift as much of
the crayon off before attempting removal. Otherwise, I
end up with a bigger smear-stain than when I started.

While goo-gone/lighter fluid (naptha) will dissolve adhesives,
they are ineffective on the dyes/colors found in crayons.

K.
 >> Stay informed about: Crayon Marks 

On Aug 5, 10:14 am, ParallelCoo... DeleteThis @gmail.com wrote:

> While goo-gone/lighter fluid (naptha) will dissolve adhesives,
> they are ineffective on the dyes/colors found in crayons.

From experience I can tell you that GooGone is effective on crayon
marks on coated stock, such as LP album covers and most DJs and
pictorial cover books.
Your suggestion about removing excessive crayon with a single edge
razor blade is a good one but you have to be VERY careful.
 >> Stay informed about: Crayon Marks