Welcome to BookForumz.com!
FAQFAQ      ProfileProfile    Private MessagesPrivate Messages   Log inLog in

It came to me in a dream

 
   Book Forums (Home) -> J.R.R. Tolkien RSS
Next:  Family Names  
Author Message
user1386

External


Since: Aug 18, 2004
Posts: 66



(Msg. 1) Posted: Tue Feb 19, 2008 6:54 pm
Post subject: It came to me in a dream
Archived from groups: alt>fan>tolkien, others (more info?)

One time I dreamed that I knew the winning numbers for the next Canadian
national lottery (the 6/49). So I went out and bought a ticket, but it
didn't win. Perhaps there's a moral in there somewhere.

I never seem to dream about wizards on towers in moonlight or voices
from afar crying "Seek for a broken sword, etc." However, supposing
the lottery dream had also included a voice telling me,
"You may buy these numbers and win, but if you do then all your new
wealth will bring a awful Doom upon you."

I'm sure glad I didn't have a dream like that, because it would be
hard to turn down 25 million dollars. Of course, logically the same
certainty about winning would also apply to the doom... or would it?

I can't imagine feeling very happy the morning after the draw,
looking at the winning numbers that I could have bought, and trying
to convince myself that missing out on the big payoff also means
avoiding the terrible (but unspecified) fate.

No, I'd probably buy the ticket, trying to convince myself that
all that money wouldn't lead me astray. Then after I won I'd quit
my job, withdrawing my contribution to the Gross National Product
and become a mere consumer of other people's products and services.

Then I'd become lazy and not achieve very much more with my life.
This is already becoming an unpleasant outlook, even without turning
into a Nazgul or something. The money would give me power, but only
according to my stature. Believe me, I'm no Alexander the Great or
Henry Ford; I haven't trained my will to the domination of others.
So I'd probably just buy myself a new motorcycle and a few other toys
and go on a permanent vacation.

And in the end, what would I have after that to look back on and
celebrate? Not much perhaps. I might become like the Duke of Windsor
who spent the later part of his life (1936 to 1972) achieving nothing
particularly significant (apart from entertaining celebrities, writing
his memoirs, embarrassing the British Government and getting involved
in scandals). Wikipedia terms his life after WW2 "in retirement";
other sources less kind call him (and his Duchess) "social parasites".

Ironically, if I'd won the lottery 10 years ago I probably wouldn't
be on the interesting project I'm on now, working with earthquake
detection. Perhaps I'll even graduate to volcanoes.

Despite all this the urge to buy the ticket would be irresistible.
I'm sure I wouldn't have the strength of character not to.

Therefore I don't think I'd be a very good candidate for Ring-Bearer,
either. So if I'm ever in some cave and find some renegade Maiar's
Ruling Ring, it'll take more than a wizard to talk me into giving
it to my nephew, let alone dropping the thing into Mount Etna.

Sean_Q_

 >> Stay informed about: It came to me in a dream 
Back to top
Login to vote
Gregory Hernandez

External


Since: Feb 03, 2008
Posts: 4



(Msg. 2) Posted: Tue Feb 19, 2008 6:54 pm
Post subject: Re: It came to me in a dream [Login to view extended thread Info.]
Archived from groups: per prev. post (more info?)

"Sean" <no.spam RemoveThis @no.spam> wrote in message
news:FBFuj.56644$Ly.42668@pd7urf1no...
> One time I dreamed that I knew the winning numbers for the next Canadian
> national lottery (the 6/49). So I went out and bought a ticket, but it
> didn't win. Perhaps there's a moral in there somewhere.
>
> I never seem to dream about wizards on towers in moonlight or voices
> from afar crying "Seek for a broken sword, etc." However, supposing
> the lottery dream had also included a voice telling me,
> "You may buy these numbers and win, but if you do then all your new
> wealth will bring a awful Doom upon you."
>
> I'm sure glad I didn't have a dream like that, because it would be
> hard to turn down 25 million dollars. Of course, logically the same
> certainty about winning would also apply to the doom... or would it?
>
> I can't imagine feeling very happy the morning after the draw,
> looking at the winning numbers that I could have bought, and trying
> to convince myself that missing out on the big payoff also means
> avoiding the terrible (but unspecified) fate.
>
> No, I'd probably buy the ticket, trying to convince myself that
> all that money wouldn't lead me astray. Then after I won I'd quit
> my job, withdrawing my contribution to the Gross National Product
> and become a mere consumer of other people's products and services.
>
> Then I'd become lazy and not achieve very much more with my life.
> This is already becoming an unpleasant outlook, even without turning
> into a Nazgul or something. The money would give me power, but only
> according to my stature. Believe me, I'm no Alexander the Great or
> Henry Ford; I haven't trained my will to the domination of others.
> So I'd probably just buy myself a new motorcycle and a few other toys
> and go on a permanent vacation.
>
> And in the end, what would I have after that to look back on and
> celebrate? Not much perhaps. I might become like the Duke of Windsor
> who spent the later part of his life (1936 to 1972) achieving nothing
> particularly significant (apart from entertaining celebrities, writing
> his memoirs, embarrassing the British Government and getting involved
> in scandals). Wikipedia terms his life after WW2 "in retirement";
> other sources less kind call him (and his Duchess) "social parasites".
>
> Ironically, if I'd won the lottery 10 years ago I probably wouldn't
> be on the interesting project I'm on now, working with earthquake
> detection. Perhaps I'll even graduate to volcanoes.
>
> Despite all this the urge to buy the ticket would be irresistible.
> I'm sure I wouldn't have the strength of character not to.
>
> Therefore I don't think I'd be a very good candidate for Ring-Bearer,
> either. So if I'm ever in some cave and find some renegade Maiar's
> Ruling Ring, it'll take more than a wizard to talk me into giving
> it to my nephew, let alone dropping the thing into Mount Etna.
>
> Sean_Q_

Yeah...what HE said...
Greg

 >> Stay informed about: It came to me in a dream 
Back to top
Login to vote
BaJoRi

External


Since: Dec 22, 2007
Posts: 17



(Msg. 3) Posted: Wed Feb 20, 2008 12:32 am
Post subject: Re: It came to me in a dream [Login to view extended thread Info.]
Archived from groups: per prev. post (more info?)

"Gregory Hernandez" <elvensmith RemoveThis @earthlink.net> wrote in message
news:13rmffgtgdrbvf2@corp.supernews.com...
>
> "Sean" <no.spam RemoveThis @no.spam> wrote in message
> news:FBFuj.56644$Ly.42668@pd7urf1no...
>> One time I dreamed that I knew the winning numbers for the next Canadian
>> national lottery (the 6/49). So I went out and bought a ticket, but it
>> didn't win. Perhaps there's a moral in there somewhere.
>>
>> I never seem to dream about wizards on towers in moonlight or voices
>> from afar crying "Seek for a broken sword, etc." However, supposing
>> the lottery dream had also included a voice telling me,
>> "You may buy these numbers and win, but if you do then all your new
>> wealth will bring a awful Doom upon you."
>>
>> I'm sure glad I didn't have a dream like that, because it would be
>> hard to turn down 25 million dollars. Of course, logically the same
>> certainty about winning would also apply to the doom... or would it?
>>
>> I can't imagine feeling very happy the morning after the draw,
>> looking at the winning numbers that I could have bought, and trying
>> to convince myself that missing out on the big payoff also means
>> avoiding the terrible (but unspecified) fate.
>>
>> No, I'd probably buy the ticket, trying to convince myself that
>> all that money wouldn't lead me astray. Then after I won I'd quit
>> my job, withdrawing my contribution to the Gross National Product
>> and become a mere consumer of other people's products and services.
>>
>> Then I'd become lazy and not achieve very much more with my life.
>> This is already becoming an unpleasant outlook, even without turning
>> into a Nazgul or something. The money would give me power, but only
>> according to my stature. Believe me, I'm no Alexander the Great or
>> Henry Ford; I haven't trained my will to the domination of others.
>> So I'd probably just buy myself a new motorcycle and a few other toys
>> and go on a permanent vacation.
>>
>> And in the end, what would I have after that to look back on and
>> celebrate? Not much perhaps. I might become like the Duke of Windsor
>> who spent the later part of his life (1936 to 1972) achieving nothing
>> particularly significant (apart from entertaining celebrities, writing
>> his memoirs, embarrassing the British Government and getting involved
>> in scandals). Wikipedia terms his life after WW2 "in retirement";
>> other sources less kind call him (and his Duchess) "social parasites".
>>
>> Ironically, if I'd won the lottery 10 years ago I probably wouldn't
>> be on the interesting project I'm on now, working with earthquake
>> detection. Perhaps I'll even graduate to volcanoes.
>>
>> Despite all this the urge to buy the ticket would be irresistible.
>> I'm sure I wouldn't have the strength of character not to.
>>
>> Therefore I don't think I'd be a very good candidate for Ring-Bearer,
>> either. So if I'm ever in some cave and find some renegade Maiar's
>> Ruling Ring, it'll take more than a wizard to talk me into giving
>> it to my nephew, let alone dropping the thing into Mount Etna.
>>
>> Sean_Q_
>
> Yeah...what HE said...
> Greg
>

I dreamed once that I ate a huge marshmallow. And when I woke up, my pillow
was gone.
 >> Stay informed about: It came to me in a dream 
Back to top
Login to vote
Gregory Hernandez

External


Since: Feb 03, 2008
Posts: 4



(Msg. 4) Posted: Wed Feb 20, 2008 12:32 am
Post subject: Re: It came to me in a dream [Login to view extended thread Info.]
Archived from groups: per prev. post (more info?)

[snip]
"BaJoRi" wrote
> I dreamed once that I ate a huge marshmallow. And when I woke up, my
> pillow was gone.

I dreamed that I was having a wild honeymoon... noisy, scrtaching, the whole
nine yards. When I woke up, since I live alone, I smiled, then shrugged,
and put the dream out of my head...but then I noticed after a while that my
cat would no longer come near me....
 >> Stay informed about: It came to me in a dream 
Back to top
Login to vote
taemon

External


Since: Feb 03, 2004
Posts: 182



(Msg. 5) Posted: Wed Feb 20, 2008 6:08 pm
Post subject: Re: It came to me in a dream [Login to view extended thread Info.]
Archived from groups: per prev. post (more info?)

Sean wrote:

> I never seem to dream about wizards on towers in moonlight or voices
> from afar crying "Seek for a broken sword, etc." However, supposing
> the lottery dream had also included a voice telling me,
> "You may buy these numbers and win, but if you do then all your new
> wealth will bring a awful Doom upon you."

I see your point... but I think "awful Doom" is too strong. Okay, you would
live quite differently from now and maybe do things you, from your current
viewpoint, look upon as worthless. Then again, you might THEN look upon your
current life as only slighty more worthwile. And who decides such things,
anyway? It is all in your own mind. So the money wouldn't change your life
so much as it would change your own mind. Change it is such a way as to
consider eternal holiday as a good thing and you're set.

....

Okay, that ring wouldn't be safe in my hands either.

T.
 >> Stay informed about: It came to me in a dream 
Back to top
Login to vote
Display posts from previous:   
   Book Forums (Home) -> J.R.R. Tolkien All times are: Pacific Time (US & Canada) (change)
Page 1 of 1

 
You can post new topics in this forum
You can reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum



[ Contact us | Terms of Service/Privacy Policy ]